Proposal for Steve Reich’s Music for 18 Musicians
What is music? Is it an art form with intrinsic quantitative properties that determine whether it is successful, or is it a more slippery thing, something that just hooks you at the right moment? Is it a product of our culture, a bell ringing from being continually struck by a million little hammers? We are quick to say “Now, that is music!” to things we love, often with a sense of relief after having endured things we dislike, sounds that are dismissed as “not even music.” Revolutionary works of music are seen as challenges to the traditional nature of the medium—stretching the parameters of what is accepted as music, violating the cultural boundaries that contain music, or radically adjusting the quantifiable elements that make up what we think of music. Stravinsky’s The Rites of Spring started a riot in the theatre. The Sex Pistols’ Never Mind the Bollocks cast the band as enemy's of culture. Run D.M.C.’s debut opened the street into the suburbs. Whether these pieces qualify as music set them apart from the crowd and because of it, they had a lasting effect on the music that followed them. Steve Reich’s Music for 18 Musicians is one of those revolutionary pieces.
Steve Reich’s music is one that bridges a lot of gaps. Its appeal spans academic and popular circles. It simultaneously exhibits conceptual rigor and breathtaking melodiousness. It is music that both fits in the bounds of “classical” music and the even dodgier sub-classification of “minimalism” and yet interfaces perfectly with the liquid world of popular music. Like his fellow “minimalists” Reich’s music bares its underlying structure through simple forms and repetition, but it’s the fantastic things that grow out from churning and tilling of the root soil of music that captures listeners’ attention. Few pieces of music are as immediately and consistently captivating as Music for 18 Musicians.
Music for 18 Musicians consists of a single track on the 1978 ECM album (broken into halves on the original vinyl release), beginning with a simple pulse that clears the slate of whatever music came before it. That heartbeat soon doubles up on itself creating cicada-like waves out of which sprout new melodies; it is like we are observing the birth of a song at a zygotic level in a Petri dish. Stray tones emerge followed by others, tiptoeing out of a primordial sea of sound. Those parades of tones evolve into melodies that ebb and flow as more musical data joins and retreats, in a rhythm established by the first breath of the clarinetist. With that first breath the music is born, it evolves, takes on a life of its own and finally, after all possibilities of existence and mood are exhausted, it returns back to the form of a pulse and suddenly as it appeared, without fanfare or solemnity, ends. It starts and stops in logical, terminal spots in the music, coiling out and retracting with a serene drama toward the endpoints. It is music that constantly discovers itself as it moves along.
Similarly, Music for 18 Musicians is perpetually being re-discovered by enterprising musicians. It has been an inspiration for prog-rockers in the 70s, icy post-punk in the 80’s, new age musicians in the 90’s, and pastoral orchestral indie rockers and cutting edge DJ’s today. It transcends the elitist bounds of the classical repertoire without sacrificing any of its intellectual and musical rigor. It is the rare piece of music that is accessible and appealing to everyone, casting a Promethean light on what is music?
Steve Reich came up in the heady musical days of the 60’s when the cultural mandate involved cutting new trails through consciousness, often leading in toward the East. Alongside fellow composers Terry Riley, Philip Glass and La Monte Young, naively classified as “minimalists”, Reich explored what happens when patterns intersect, when you allow the structure of sound to reveal its interior properties through repetition. Echoes of his early tape pieces It’s Gonna Rain and Come Out, as well as his Happening-influenced Pendulum Music (where he allowed microphones to swing from their cords over amplifiers so that the undulating waves of feedback work their way toward equilibrium) can be heard in Music for 18 Musicians. Reich studied Indian raga and Gamelan percussion orchestras, using the drone and continuum intrinsic to these exotic Eastern textures as rich soil in which new ideas can flower. But where much Eastern-tinged music of the era bears a dated hippie patina, Music for 18 Musicians eschews any exotic trappings to get to the essence of drone, repetition, evolution and melody, to create something pure and timeless.
Its original recording on a 1978 release on ECM broke the barrier of how classical, or more correctly, art music is presented. Usually a classical record occupies in intersection of piece and performer, each indexed similarly as the ingredients for a boxed dinner. Music for 18 Musicians is different –the iconic grey cover with the close-up photo of a fabric’s weave, the simple, generic name of his performing ensemble “Steve Reich and Musicians” as well as Music for 18 Musicians itself, implying a Platonic elevation, an ideal. The assertion in this simple phrasing implies here is a composer and musicians, and they are playing music, short-circuiting any of the trappings of oblique opus numbers or conductors’ names or ensembles whose names should inspire awe in those elite enough to recognize them. The name Music for 18 Musicians says everything you need to know about this piece of music, and by extension the experience of music itself.
In my book length treatment of Music for 18 Musicians, I will mirror the structure of this piece, allowing the topics discussed above to emerge out of a continuing narrative that begins and ends at the philosophical “pulse” points: asking “what is music?” at the beginning and emerging at the end with an answer. In between these poles, I will explore the climate of “minimalism” in which Reich participated, compare and contrast his work with other “minimalist” composers, explain the technical details of how the piece works in simple enough terms that a novice can understand them, chart Reich’s trajectory as a composer before and after Music for 18 Musicians, and discuss the philosophical nature of the work and of music itself. Like listening to the piece, my book will be an informed, evolving meditation on the music at hand and music in general.
Along with analyzing the piece itself, I plan to interview Mr. Reich and the musicians involved with the original recording, as well as his fellow “minimalist” composers Philip Glass, La Monte Young, and Terry Riley. I also plan to interview Evan Zipoyn, clarinetist for Bang on a Can All-Stars who has been involved in subsequent recordings of the piece. I would include interviews with Alex Patterson of The Orb, who used Reich’s Electric Counterpoint as the basis of their massive hit “Little Fluffy Clouds”, as well as Coldcut, who remixed Music for 18 Musicians as a part of the 2008 Reich Remixed album. I would also interview Marc Mellits, the doctoral student who created a full written score for the piece in 1995 as a part of his thesis on the piece, allowing it to be performed successfully by ensembles outside of those of the composer.
Part of what makes Music for 18 Musicians such an astonishing piece of music is that, outside of any historical, philosophical or architectural analysis we can perform on it, it remains consistently undeniably warm and immediately welcoming. I will include four personal interludes of how I experienced this piece:
- First hearing it on the radio in my college dorm room, my roommate and I found ourselves sitting on the floor in a trance as it unfolded
- Playing it for my girlfriend’s dad who saw it as a soothing balm for a life that wasonstantly coming unraveled
- Playing it for my estranged classical snob father who conceded that this was a new stretching of music, realizing there is more to experience out there beyond the accepted classics of Mozart and Beethoven
- Playing it for my seven-year old daughter as we painted a flowerpot for my wife’s birthday present, where the slow easy transformation of structure and form was natural to her
I think weaving these personal experiences into the mechanics of the piece reflect the nature of Music for 18 Musicians – here is a composer and here is a musician and the here is the music they are playing and here you are listening to it, and that is the fundamental answer to “what is music?”. I feel it’s important to not overload analysis with anecdotes, but I think it is pertinant when you are talking about something as personal as music. I want this book to be as natural, welcoming, and evocative as listening to the music. I recently finished Drew Daniels’ book on Throbbing Gristle and was inspired how he walks you through the album, building his context as he went along so that you emerge at the end with a complete picture of the music, the methods and the philosophy behind it.
I think this would be a marketable contribution to your series, in that it is one that comes up frequently in discussions about your book series (for instance, when Idolator.com reprinted your announcement, it was the third topic to come up). It would have the novelty of being one of the first outside of the pop/rock realm without losing its connection to it. The album cover will look great rendered in your format. Plus Steve Reich is very much in the vernacular of popular music, name-checked everywhere from jazz and classical writing to Pitchfork. I would love nothing better than the chance to further the discovery and re-discovery of this record through the auspices of your book series.
Alex V. Cook
I am a music critic and music enthusiast living and working in Baton Rouge, LA. My take on music criticism is that one must push past the gossipy artist biographies that make up so much music writing and get to the actual heart of music to make it personal and make it universal. When asked how I know when a piece of music or art works, I describe it as riding on one train while another moves in the opposite direction, and suddenly you make instant eye contact with a person on that other train, and in that instant there is a huge bond, a “knowing” that you don’t get anywhere else. It’s not about the circumstances of how you or that other rider got on the train, or about the different routes the trains make, nor is it about any real factual information being exchanged. The success of a piece of art lies in that personal connection, and once you have that, then the details that lead up to it become illuminating.
In my writing about music, I strive to achieve that balance between the music and the listener, twining anecdote, background information and lucid (and humorous) description into a strong rope with which I hopefully capture the essence of a work without hanging myself in the process. My first book Darkness, Racket and Twang: Essential Listening from the Fringes of Popular and Unpopular Music (SideCartel, 2006) as well as my long-form album reviews at outsideleft.com center around that connection between the listener and the music. My publisher put it best by saying “It is as much travel writing, documenting the terrain of the music-obsessed, as it is criticism.” My second book, I Become a Transparent iPod, slated for publication in the spring of 2009, is a set of personal essays exploring music’s transcendent nature, how you can find yourself through it.
My writing in The Oxford American, The Believer, The Wire, DownBeat as well as local columns in 225 Magazine and Country Roads reflects this desire to illuminate the exhilaration of discovery and processing of music. I am committed to this endeavor through my work, willing to go anywhere and talk to anyone to continue it. I have wanted to write this book ever since I read my first 33 1/3 book about Sign O’ the Times a number of years ago.
No comments:
Post a Comment